By: Marco C. Iafrate
October 30, 2026
In this article we will see if the Ludington City Charter and the City’s interpretations of Section 10.8 aligns with the U.S. Constitution. I have read the City Charter like a book twice over now because I know repetition increases memory.
Section 10.8 of our Ludington Charter tells us: “The positions and duties of Administrative Officers for which provision is not made herein, shall be established by ordinance. The Council, upon recommendation by the City Manager, may prescribe additional powers and duties, not inconsistent with this charter, to be exercised by appropriate officers and departments of the city.”
The City wants to create a new position, the Finance Director, which would be an entirely new office. They are using this part of Section 10.8 “The positions and duties of Administrative Officers for which provision is not made herein, shall be established by ordinance” as the means to create the new position.
By this language, the City tells us in their Charter Amendment FAQ that they can still hire a FD whether the ballot vote results pass it or not.
What I am is a Constitutionalist. My reason for reading the Charter so much is to see where it does and does not align with the U.S. Constitution. A charter is a local constitution, it is described by many, many cities across the United States.
Webster’s Dictionary defined a Charter as: “any instrument executed with form and solemnity bestowing or granting powers, rights, and privileges.
Webster’s defined Constitution as: “the act of constituting, enacting, establishing, or appointing the specific structure and connection of parts which makes or characterizes a system or body, the established form of government in a state, a system of fundamental rules, principles, and ordinances for a the government of a state or nation.”
What these have in common is they set the record straight about how to put the government in order. Only the charter is underneath the Constitution.
Ludington is one among many Michigan cities refusing to go by the U.S. Constitution, and instead do their own thing because the State of Michigan Constitution gets amended resulting in misalignment with the U.S. Constitution.
Our Charter says in Section 2.1: “The City of Ludington shall have all powers possible for a city to have under the Constitution and laws of the State of Michigan as fully and completely as though they were specifically enumerated in this Charter.”
But the City of Ludington as a majority chooses the misaligned constitution of the State of Michigan over the Constitution itself.
Amendment 15 Section 1 of our nation’s Constitution says: “The Right of Citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or Abridged…”
Webster’s defined Abridge as: “lessen” or “diminish.”
In the Charter Amendment FAQ it says: “Can the City proceed with hiring a Finance Director regardless of the outcome of the November Election? Yes. City Charter Section 10.8 permits the City Council by ordinance to create and empower other administrative positions not specified in the Charter. This would include creating a new position for finance director.”
So, if the Majority votes the Charter Amendment down but the City decides to hire a Finance Director anyway, they will have diminished and lessened and abridged the U.S. Constitution’s 15th Amendment, the Right to Vote.
The Public Vote will have been made to no effect.
The only way to not Abridge the 15th Amendment is to take the ballot results as the final say, and not manipulate the votes.
Kaitlyn Aldrich wants to Oversee the Finance Director
In the FAQ, the City tells us they want to appoint the Finance Director and take the position from the Clerk’s oversight and put it under the City Manager, Aldrich.
I will say that creating a Finance Director position separate from the Clerk’s oversight would be ok only if Kaitlyn Aldrich was not our City Manager.
I investigated her former employment as the Planning Assistant in the Planning Department of Traverse City. I talked with her former colleagues at city hall and I looked at all the records of housing and developments over the span of her time there and what the cost of living was then and now. I learned that the same cost of living increases that happened there have been taking shape in our city.
Costs have been increasing in the same manner in our town before Kaitlyn arrived and I believe her vision for Ludington is aligned with the Good ol’ Boys Club here, and they are misaligned with the Law of the Land.
The Charter Amendment FAQ and the lips of Aldrich tell us the Clerk’s Office is overburdened but we have not heard a formal statement on this from current Clerk Deborah Luskin.
On this point I will say it’s all in the attitude, there is a reason the brain is at the highest point of the human body. If you gotta push through the hardship then push for the well-being of the city and everyone in it. I think Deb has this attitude and I think anyone else can have it too.
It’s exactly what John F. Kennedy said, which I will paraphrase: Ask not what your city can do for you… ask what you can do for your city.”
Kaitlyn announced an important thing once at a recent City Council meeting, she said that the next councilors coming in need to be prepared to face a city that is in deficit. I say now to my fellow earnest candidates and incumbents that we need to be ready to get under the financial burden this city has and lift together as a team.
We all have certain skills and gifts, and we have character, we have our integrity and not too much of a desire to shout about it on the rooftops.
Our People do not need us to make excuses. Those will not save our city, only pushing as a team will.
I think we need to take a good look at the fact that the City Manager wants the financial duty under her supervision and at the same time wants the new City Councilors to be prepared to manage our City in financial deficit.
That fact is scented like our marinas in the peak of fishing season.
If the finances become her responsibility we will have to fight harder to get this city back on track than if they weren’t under her supervision.
I also think Curtis Shields’ opinion is just as important as the City Manager. Shields is running for the Clerk office uncontested. If he thinks he can find a way to take on all the duties as head of the Clerk office, then it would be better to keep the financial duty in the Clerk’s office and not move it over and under the City Manager.
Where there is a will there is a way.
Sincerely in Your Trust,
Marco C. Iafrate
4th Ward Watchman – City Council Candidate – Ludington Investigator
Leave a Reply